March 18, 2026

The Case for Buying an Old House

(It’s not what you think.)

In a world where everyone is outbidding each other on new builds, new additions, new homes – we say, let them have it.

We’ll take a 1920s Spanish, a 1930s Tudor, a slightly creaky Craftsman with original windows almost every time.

And it’s not just because we’re emotional. (Okay fine, it’s a little because we’re emotional.) But mostly, it’s because we believe it’s the smarter bet.

You can build new. You can’t build old.

The thing is, you can build a new house tomorrow. You cannot build a 1920s original.

You can try…and people do. But you can’t recreate what’s original. And that matters.

In Los Angeles, many of the homes people love most were built between the 1910s and 1940s. That era is finite. There are only so many of those homes left. And every year, more of them get torn down.

Our main case for buying old? Scarcity is what drives value. Not trend.

The best homes weren’t built to sell.

A lot of new construction today is built for speed and resale. “Maximize square footage! Hit the right keywords! Photograph well!”

And listen, we get it. There are beautiful new builds. But many of them are designed for a moment.

The older homes we’re talking about? They were built differently. With intention. With craftsmanship. With materials meant to last. There’s a reason you walk into one and immediately feel the difference. (And it’s not ghosts.)

Your body knows before your brain does.

We say this all the time, but it’s worth repeating: You can look at 100 houses online and feel nothing. And then you walk into one, and everything clicks.

That’s not random. Older homes tend to get the fundamentals right:

  • proportions that make sense

  • natural light that moves the way it should

  • layouts that weren’t over-engineered

There’s real research showing that natural materials and daylight impact how we feel in a space: lowering stress and improving mood.

So when you walk in and exhale? That’s not just “vibes.” That’s your body recognizing something good.

Not every old house is worth it.

We’re not blindly romantic about this. Some old homes have been over-renovated. Or lost their original details. Some just don’t work anymore, and honestly aren’t worth saving.

But the good ones? They have something you cannot add later.

What to look for in an old house (save this).

So at the end of the day, here’s what matters:

1. Original details still intact
Windows, moldings, doors, tile (because once they’re gone, they’re gone).

2. Good light (non-negotiable)
If it’s too dark, nothing else matters.

3. A layout that mostly makes sense
You can tweak. You don’t want to completely reconfigure it.

4. Real, solid materials
Wood. Plaster. Stone. Things that age well, and look timeless.

5. It hasn’t been over-reimagined
If it’s trying too hard to be “modern,” it usually lost the plot.

6. You feel something when you walk in
More than anything else, this is how you know it’s yours.

The reality: Old homes hold value.

Because older homes are scarce, and because buyers consistently gravitate toward character, walkable neighborhoods, and architectural integrity – they tend to hold long-term appeal in a way trend-driven new builds sometimes don’t. Yes, you’re buying a house. More than that, you’re buying something that already proved it can last.

Closing argument.

We’ll take the house with the good bones. The better light. The one with history and feeling. Every time.

If you’re looking right now, send us what you’re deciding between.

Old vs new. Character vs clean.

We’ll tell you honestly what we’d do.

2644

Greenvalley Rd

“A screenwriter lived here, and you can tell, because every corner of the property feels like its own scene.”

–Sam O’Connor
$3,495,000
3,024 SQ. FT.
3 BEDS
3 BATHS

Most houses in the hills are sold on a single view, and everything else exists to support it. This one works more like a screenplay. It opens at the gate and the long driveway, introduces the house through walls of glass and a pool, and then moves outward through a courtyard, a guest house, a Zen garden, and an outdoor theater before closing on the upper deck, where the city and the Hollywood Sign come into view. That structure is the real reason the property feels larger than its half acre. Every space has a purpose and a time of day, so the place never runs out of somewhere new to be. It belongs to someone who writes, makes, or produces something, who needs a studio across the courtyard and a deck to end the day on, and who knows that the best scenes are the ones you build up to.

2810

Woodshire Dr

“The Hollywood sign started as an ad for this neighborhood. A hundred years later, houses like this one are still the best argument for it.”

–Sam O’Connor
$3,895,000
2,833 SQ. FT.
4 BEDS
3 BATHS

There is a difference between renovating a historic house and restoring one, and most of it is invisible. A renovation is what you see: the marble, the hardware, the new kitchen. A restoration is everything nobody notices, like original windows rebuilt instead of swapped for new ones, or a fountain kept running for nearly a hundred years when it would have been easier to pull it out. Plenty of Spanish houses in Los Angeles get the first treatment and skip the second, and they end up looking like period pieces without feeling like them. Villa Alesia got both, because the builder who did the work also chose to live inside it. It belongs to someone who walks down to Beachwood Village for coffee, hikes Lake Hollywood before work, and comes home to a house that was already here when the sign still said Hollywoodland.

2449

Panorama Ter

“An architect builds differently when he’s the one who has to live there.”

–Claire O’Connor
$2,395,000
2,234 SQ. FT.
5 BEDS
2 BATHS

An architect builds differently when he is the one who has to live there. Designing for a client is a negotiation, and every house that comes out of one carries the marks of what was traded away. A house built for the architect’s own family has no one to negotiate with, which makes it the most honest version of his thinking: the beams he actually wanted, the built-ins he actually used, the hearth placed exactly where he wanted to sit. Then there are the avocado trees. A man who plants fruit trees at his own house is planning for decades, not for a photo shoot, and the trees are still producing today. That is the real proof of how this house was made. It belongs to someone who will pick the avocados, read by the garden, and understand that they are living inside one person’s best argument.

3145

Abington Dr

“Most people book a resort to live like this for a week. Here, you just come home.”

–Claire O’Connor
$8,495,000
4,027 SQ. FT.
5 BEDS
5 BATHS

Beverly Hills has always built two kinds of estates. The first is built for the drive past, with a facade, a motor court, and a lawn meant mainly to be looked at. The second is built for the people inside the gate, and it spends its money where no passerby will ever see it. This house is firmly the second kind, and the fireplaces make the case: there are six of them, counting the fire pit, and every one sits behind the gate. Add a theater, a cabana, a gazebo, and a pool, and the list starts reading as a decision. The point of the house is that going out becomes optional. In a city where every address is public, that is the one kind of privacy money can still buy, and it belongs to someone who has done plenty of going out and would now rather have everyone come over.

8420

Ridpath Dr

“Most houses are built around a kitchen. This one was built around a redwood.”

–Sam O’Connor
$2,850,000
2,636 SQ. FT.
4 BEDS
3 BATHS

Most houses get sold by erasing the people who lived in them. The walls get painted, the photographs come down, and the house becomes a blank space. The sellers here did the opposite and wrote out everything that happened inside it, from marriage and parenthood to music and a great deal of dancing. Anywhere else that would read as sentimental. In Laurel Canyon it reads as accurate, because the canyon earned its reputation through people who treated houses as places where things happened rather than as assets. The redwood makes the argument permanent. A tree that has grown through the center of a house for a century is not something a new owner can renovate around, so whoever buys it is not starting over so much as taking a turn. It belongs to a family in the Wonderland school district who want the noise and know exactly what to do with a lawn.

1949

Micheltorena St

“Lautner drew a studio for an artist in 1955. Seventy-one years later, it’s ready for the next one.”

–Claire O’Connor
$2,099,999
1,679 SQ. FT.
3 BEDS
2 BATHS

Custom houses usually get built around someone’s taste, and taste is the first thing a house outlives. The next owner arrives with different ideas, and the walls start moving. This one was built around something steadier, which was the work that would happen inside it. Lautner gave Joseph Baldwin a studio of his own off the heart of the house, facing north for the even light painters have always wanted. Home and work share a wall, so the house never had to choose between them. A room drawn for a job does not date the way a room drawn for a mood does, because north light is the same in every decade. It is the best explanation we have for why nobody ever felt the need to start over. This is a house for someone who makes things, in a room Lautner drew for exactly that.

Scroll to Top

The view from O’Connor Estates. Weekly.

Listings, sold stories, design inspo, and insider tips straight to your inbox.

By signing up, you agree to receive email marketing.